Optimizing Garbage Collection in Rails with Autotuner

Garbage collection (GC) is an essential part of Ruby’s memory management system, but it can sometimes introduce performance bottlenecks, especially in web applications running in production. For Rails applications, optimizing GC behavior can lead to improved response times, faster boot-ups, and reduced resource usage. The Autotuner gem provides an intelligent way to analyze GC performance and offer tuning suggestions for Rails apps. In this article, we will explore how to integrate Autotuner into your Rails application and experiment with its GC tuning recommendations.



The inspiration for this article came from this insightful and informative video, which provides a thorough exploration of garbage collection optimization in Ruby


Do you need more hands for your Ruby on Rails project?
Fill out our form! >>


What is Autotuner?

Autotuner is a tool designed to optimize the performance of Ruby on Rails applications by fine-tuning the garbage collector (GC). It integrates seamlessly with Rails as middleware and collects data on GC activity between requests. Based on this data, Autotuner offers actionable suggestions to help reduce GC overhead, improving the bootup time, warmup, and overall response times of your application.

How Does Autotuner Work?

Autotuner tracks garbage collection events in your Rails application and analyzes these events to make intelligent suggestions on how to adjust the GC settings. The gem provides insights into:

  • GC performance: How much time is spent on GC during requests.
  • Major vs Minor GC: The number of major and minor garbage collection cycles.
  • Heap size: How much memory is used by your application.
  • Request times: The duration of requests, allowing Autotuner to correlate GC performance with app response times.

Autotuner’s suggestions are not guaranteed to be perfect for every application, so it’s recommended to experiment with these suggestions in a controlled manner to determine their impact on your app.


Installing Autotuner

To get started with Autotuner, you can add it to your Rails application via Bundler. First, include the gem in your Gemfile:

gem 'autotuner'

Then run the following command to install it:

$ bundle add autotuner

Configuring Autotuner

Once installed, you need to enable Autotuner in your Rails app. The configuration process involves two main steps:

  • Adding the Middleware

Open your config.ru file and add the following line above run(Rails.application):

use(Autotuner::RackPlugin)
  • Creating an Initializer

In config/initializers/autotuner.rb, enable Autotuner and set up the reporting callbacks:

# Enable autotuner
Autotuner.enabled = true

# Define a callback to handle reports
Autotuner.reporter = proc do |report|
  Rails.logger.info(report.to_s)
end

# Define a callback to collect metrics (optional)
Autotuner.metrics_reporter = proc do |metrics|
  metrics.each do |key, val|
    StatsD.gauge(key, val)
  end
end

Experimenting with GC Tuning Suggestions

Autotuner provides suggestions based on its analysis, but it’s important to approach these suggestions with caution. Some tuning adjustments may improve performance in certain areas but have negative trade-offs in others.

Here’s how you can experiment with Autotuner’s suggestions:

  1. Collect System Metrics: Before applying any changes, make sure you are collecting important metrics such as GC time, request time, heap pages, and GC cycles. This allows you to measure the impact of changes on your app.
  2. Create Experimental Groups: Split your production environment into two groups: a default group and an experimental group. This will allow you to compare performance with and without the GC suggestions. Aim to assign a portion of your instances (between 5% and 50%) to the experimental group, depending on your traffic volume.
  3. Apply and Test Suggestions: Apply one suggestion at a time to the experimental group and observe its effects. Look for improvements in average response time, warmup time after a deploy, and GC-related metrics. Monitor the 50th, 99th, and 99.9th percentiles to measure the impact of each change.
  4. Evaluate Trade-offs: Some suggestions might improve average response times but worsen extreme cases. It’s important to weigh the trade-offs and determine if the benefits outweigh the downsides for your application’s performance.
  5. Roll Out Positive Changes: If a suggestion leads to improvements, apply it to the default group and continue experimenting with other suggestions. If a suggestion negatively impacts performance, discard it and move on to the next.

Key Configuration Options

Autotuner offers several configurable options to tailor its behavior to your app’s needs:

  1. Autotuner.enabled: Enable or disable Autotuner. Defaults to false.
  2. Autotuner.sample_ratio: Specify the portion of instances that should have Autotuner enabled. Values range from 0 (disabled) to 1.0 (enabled for all instances).
  3. Autotuner.reporter: A callback to handle GC suggestions.
  4. Autotuner.metrics_reporter: A callback to collect metrics such as GC time, request time, and heap usage.

Emitted Metrics

Autotuner provides several important metrics that you can use to track performance improvements:

These metrics can be sent to observability services like Datadog, Prometheus, or New Relic to help you monitor GC performance.


Conclusion

Autotuner provides a powerful and flexible way to optimize garbage collection in Rails applications. By intelligently analyzing GC performance and suggesting tuning adjustments, Autotuner can help improve response times, reduce memory usage, and speed up application boot times. Remember to experiment with the suggestions in a controlled environment, monitor the impact carefully, and adjust configurations as necessary to find the best balance for your application.

Leave a comment